Case on Toxic Ammonia Emissions May Proceed


Posted on July 8th, 2016

From our Partners The Humane Society

A North Carolina Federal Court ruled that an air pollution lawsuit involving a massive pig factory farm may proceed. The lawsuit against The Hanor Company of Wisconsin was brought by The Humane Society of the United States and Sound Rivers, Inc. and involves the factory farm’s refusal to report its ammonia emissions, which harm animals, the public and the environment.

Jonathan Lovvorn, chief counsel for Animal Protection Litigation for The HSUS, said: “Animal factories like this one a_67P0564-300x200harm millions of animals by forcing them to live with dangerous levels of air pollution that are also damaging the health and quality of life of those living in rural communities.”

Heather Deck, Pamlico-Tar riverkeeper for Sound Rivers said: “Large industrial-scale animal operations like Hanor are a major source of pollution that affects people and the environment.  We are pleased with the judge’s ruling and we will continue to seek protections for the communities we serve throughout the Tar-Pamlico and Neuse River basins.”

Enforcement of federal air pollution laws is sorely needed because of the approximately 20,000 concentrated animal feeding operations in the U.S. inhumanely confining billions of chickens, pigs and other animals and emitting dangerous air pollutants, including ammonia. Animal agriculture is the nation’s leading source of ammonia emissions, which can cause nasal, throat and eye irritation, coughs and even death. Ammonia damages air and water quality, and endangers wildlife and their habitat.

Because the Hanor facility confines more than 8,000 pigs, it produces excrement on a scale matching that of a small city. Unlike a city, the facility’s waste is not carefully piped and treated; instead, it piles up and putrefies in giant open pits. The facility’s stench and ammonia emissions often force neighbors indoors and prevent residents from using the Tar River for recreation.

The Court rejected Hanor’s argument that an 11-year-old agreement with the Bush administration’s EPA allows more than 13,000 CAFOs to continually violate key air pollution laws while EPA studied CAFO air pollution. Notably, EPA has never completed the air studies at issue.

One such law, the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act, requires emitters of large amounts of dangerous substances like ammonia to report those emissions to local authorities. The Hanor facility has not reported its ammonia emissions under this law since 2011.

The HSUS and Sound Rivers are represented by James L. Conner, II of Calhoun, Bhella & Sechrest, LLP in Durham, N.C., Daniel C. Snyder of the Law Offices of Charles M. Tebbutt, P.C. and lawyers with The HSUS Animal Protection Litigation section.

Related News

Trash Traps weather the storm September 28th 2023
Ophelia brings unexpected impacts September 28th 2023
Monthly Swim Guide sampling starts this week September 28th 2023
Sound Rivers investigates discolored water on upper Tar September 28th 2023
Sound Rivers welcomes new Pamlico-Tar Riverkeeper September 21st 2023
People’s Hearing sets community organizing example September 21st 2023